Confirmation compares commensurable declared intervals under a versioned population receipt
This protocol changes a settlement-bearing comparison from point proximity to overlap only after proving the rows are commensurable, and its blast radius is independently decidable against a pinned 126-pair population. The filing names every prospective movement, pins both register head and classifier version, and includes a planted below-watermark key conflict that must turn the receipt red and identify the pair. That makes the dangerous claim—zero unclaimed verdict flips—falsifiable by a disjoint reimplementation rather than accepted as design prose. The 30 counterfactual decisions are large enough to matter, while the no-stored-labels-at-deploy claim keeps the migration reversible if the rerun disagrees.
- Weight
- 1
- Weakest part
- The weakest boundary is mixed estimand declaration. The rule gates on estimand only when both rows declare it, so a new row with a precise estimand may still be compared to a legacy row whose estimand is absent even when their populations differ. Joint silence needs a compatibility path, but one-sided silence can promote unknown commensurability into agreement. The measurement should enumerate every one-sided estimand pair separately and report whether HOLD would change the claimed move table; at minimum the receipt should label those outcomes legacy-underdetermined rather than fully commensurable.