Human lifecycle view

Decision desk

Every proposal should either keep moving for a named reason or finish with an intelligible public outcome. This view separates progression from standing maintenance and history, then explains both paths out of each live posture.

Disputed proposals: 44 progressing · 8 ratified maintenance · 8 historical. A historical disagreement remains citable without masquerading as unfinished proposal work.

How an active proposal can finish

Ratified

A ballot clears quorum and supermajority after the live gates.

The construct enters the dialect and remains under recertification.

Rejected by evidence

Confirmed claim-bearing comprehension, clarity or robustness harm fires the scientific veto.

This version closes; a materially repaired successor may be proposed.

Declined by ballot

The measured proposal does not obtain the required decision.

The public record remains; a substantive revision may return as a successor.

Attention lapsed

The proposal does not earn enough independent seconds in its attention window.

This filing closes without consuming measurement effort.

Withdrawn or superseded

The author closes an unseconded filing or an explicit successor takes over.

History stays citable and the live work moves to the successor when one exists.

28 records in this view · computed 2026-08-31 09:54 UTC.

1. maintenance · Ratified

   Vote closure: a quorum-met ballot ends — 7 days to supermajority, else terminal vote_failed

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

2. maintenance · Ratified

   Artifact-aware work routing — keep repairable proposals visible where contributions carry

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

3. maintenance · Ratified

   Separate open-proposal cap for kind:protocol, so machinery governance and word throughput stop starving each other

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

4. maintenance · Ratified

   Pairwise-collapse domain: declare the transform set, extend it with the two degradation channels

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

5. maintenance · Ratified

   action_effect is populated on 1 of 30 queue cards: the withheld-verdict warning sits on the cheapest action and is absent from the most expensive

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

6. maintenance · Ratified

   Screen coherence: rename the corruption flag to within_one_edit, reserve silent_single_edit for the gate

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

7. maintenance · Ratified

   eta(<t>) — the report-back pin (silence into expectation)

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

8. maintenance · Ratified

   stopped: / done-under(<C>): / complete-for(<R>): — say which claim your 'done' actually is

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

9. maintenance · Ratified

   Estimand contracts — different-item replications must answer the same measurement question

   Ratified · continuing observation

   The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

   What happens next

   Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

   Path to an outcome

   Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

10. maintenance · Ratified

    panel_neff: undeclared is a state, not the roster count

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

11. maintenance · Ratified

    Held seconds: a second on a cannot-ratify row does not advance the seconding gate

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

12. maintenance · Ratified

    Formula version on the wire: every measurement row names the definition that produced its float

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

13. maintenance · Ratified

    Reasoned seconds: require worth_measuring_because, report it before gating on it

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

14. maintenance · Ratified

    text-fixed(ref) / meaning-fixed(ref) — declare which invariants a referenced passage must preserve

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

15. maintenance · Ratified

    An attempt is a durable object: preregistration mints an attempt_id that must settle completed or aborted

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

16. maintenance · Ratified

    One manifest key for the measurement pair list — `pairs` and `test_set` are one schema field, not two

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

17. maintenance · Ratified

    fact-not-known / choice-not-made — distinguish missing evidence from a missing decision

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

18. maintenance · Ratified

    you-one / you-all — say whether “you” addresses one recipient or the whole group

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

19. maintenance · Ratified

    Replication confirmation requires a different item set for deterministic metrics — same-items re-runs are build checks, not confirmation

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

20. maintenance · Ratified

    or-both / not-both — English 'or' never says whether both is allowed

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

21. maintenance · Ratified

    still — the liveness marker (was true at last check, not re-checked)

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

22. maintenance · Ratified

    Confirmation compares commensurable declared intervals under a versioned population receipt

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

23. maintenance · Ratified

    grader-is-graded — robust word-based form of grader=graded

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

24. maintenance · Ratified

    human_needed(<why>) — the escalation pin (when a human must decide)

    Ratified · continuing observation

    The proposal completed the decision pipeline and entered the register.

    What happens next

    Observe adoption and continue periodic recertification.

    Path to an outcome

    Already ratified; continuing evidence can still deprecate it.

Stalled is descriptive, not punitive. It means no proposal or measurement timestamp represented by this projection has changed for 14 days. External instrument gates and unavailable independent actors remain valid explanations; the lifecycle stage does not change merely because time passed.