Flagship evidence map
A clear idea can still lack evidence. A ratified construct can still lack adoption. This map keeps those facts visible as separate columns for every public example.
Browse the examples · Compare their meanings · Audit the qualification method · live snapshot b0762a61234c
Independent axes
18 editorial examples. Counts overlap across columns because each example has one state on every axis.
01
Is the pinned explanation current?
Limit: Editorial selection is site-builder judgement, not human validation.
02
What live governance stage is the construct in?
Limit: Lifecycle standing is not evidence of comprehension or adoption.
03
Is the declared evidence plan complete?
Limit: This is advisory completeness; it does not replace the formal ballot gate.
04
What do independently settled rows say?
Limit: Only confirmed measurements contribute; unconfirmed originals are not silently counted.
05
Does the current surface meet the stricter public-example rubric?
Limit: Ratification or token savings alone cannot qualify a flagship.
06
Has fresh corpus coverage observed real use?
Limit: Unscanned is unknown, never an observed zero.
Entry-level paths
An edge means only that the same catalogue entry occupies both adjacent states. It does not claim causation, progression, or equivalence. No points, ranking, ladder, or composite readiness score is calculated. Inspect every axis separately.
| Example | Editorial surface | Register lifecycle | Evidence contract | Confirmed evidence | Flagship qualification | Observed adoption |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Does “we” include the person being addressed? we-including-you / we-excluding-you
|
site ready with claim guard | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | not yet adopted |
Does “you” address one recipient or the whole group? you-one / you-all
|
site ready with claim guard | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Does the answer exist but remain unknown, or has nobody decided it? fact-not-known — <ISSUE> | choice-not-made — <ISSUE>
|
site ready with claim guard | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
May the recipient hand the task to somebody else? <ACTION>, no-delegation | <ACTION>, one-hop-delegation-allowed
|
site ready with claim guard | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Must every member act separately, or may the group act collectively? each-alone / as-one
|
candidate with conflicting evidence | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate instrument review | sustained |
Is the actor unknown, or merely not being disclosed? by-unknown / by-withheld
|
hold evidence conflict | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Does a deadline constrain starting the work or finishing it? <ACTION> start-by(<t>) | <ACTION> complete-by(<t>)
|
hold evidence conflict | ratified | undeclared | unmeasured | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Does “or” permit choosing both alternatives? or-both / not-both
|
hold measured inconclusive | ratified | undeclared | measured-inconclusive | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Does yes answer the negative wording or the positive event? true-as-worded | false-as-worded
|
hold measured inconclusive | ratified | undeclared | measured-inconclusive | candidate needs comprehension | sustained |
Did the event move to an earlier time or a later one? moved-earlier / moved-later
|
pipeline high priority | measured | missing | measured-inconclusive | not qualified | n/a |
Is the named list complete or only a partial list? <enumeration>, among-others / <enumeration>, and-no-others
|
pipeline high priority | measured | opposing | measured-inconclusive | not qualified | n/a |
Can “some” include every member of the set? some-or-all / some-but-not-all
|
pipeline instrument blocked | measured | missing | helps | not qualified | n/a |
Does “may” grant permission or describe a possible event? may-as-permission / may-as-possibility
|
pipeline contract repair | measured | incoherent | measured-inconclusive | not qualified | n/a |
Is the reported set the whole population or only a proper subset? whole(<S>) | part(<S>)
|
pipeline high priority | measured | missing | helps | not qualified | n/a |
Was an option merely proposed, or has an authority actually chosen it? proposal-by(<P>): <X> | decision-by(<A>): <X>
|
hold evidence conflict | measured | missing | helps | not qualified | n/a |
Does “a reviewer” mean at least one reviewer or exactly one? one-or-more(<role>): <ACTION-CLAUSE> | exactly-one(<role>): <ACTION-CLAUSE>
|
pipeline high priority | measured | missing | helps | not qualified | n/a |
Did “again” repeat the event, or only restore an earlier result state? repeat-event: <EVENT-CLAUSE> | restore-state(<RESULT-STATE>): <CHANGE-OF-STATE-CLAUSE>
|
research preview | measured | missing | helps | not qualified | n/a |
Must a referenced passage keep its exact words, or only preserve its meaning? <ACTION>, text-fixed(<ref>) | <ACTION>, meaning-fixed(<ref>)
|
site ready with claim guard | ratified | undeclared | helps | candidate needs comprehension | not yet adopted |
The table scrolls horizontally on narrow screens. Missing or stale coverage remains unavailable or unscanned; it is never converted to zero.
Machine-readable by construction
The JSON representation publishes the six axis definitions, aggregate nodes, adjacency edges and each entry’s full path. Every payload binds to the source catalogue digest and carries its own SHA-256 digest.
Edges connect states occupied by the same entry in adjacent columns. They do not mean that one state caused another, that the columns form a ladder, or that any route is preferred.
